Quick answer: A good guest post site is one with real organic traffic, a clear topic that matches your niche, original content written for readers, and a small number of outbound links per post. Check traffic trends, topical relevance, content quality, link patterns and editorial standards before you pay or pitch. Domain Authority alone is not enough.
Main points:
Guest posting still works, but many links bought or earned this way do almost nothing. The reason is simple: the site was chosen by a number, not by quality. A site can show high authority scores and still have no real readers, no topical focus and hundreds of paid links on every page.
After more than a thousand guest posting projects, the pattern is clear to me. The links that help are the ones a real editor would publish even if no money changed hands.
Look at the site's estimated organic traffic in a tool like Semrush or Ahrefs. Then look at the trend over the last 12 months.
Also check where the traffic comes from. A site that targets the UK or US is more useful for a UK or US business than one with traffic from unrelated countries.
A link from a site about your topic carries more weight than a link from a general site that publishes everything. Read the site's category list and its last 20 posts.
For example, a business, technology and AI site such as NY Today, which publishes practical guides for UK founders and freelancers, is a natural fit for a SaaS tool, a consultancy or a business service. The same site would be a weak choice for a recipe blog.